Two of the Brickmuppet's Crack Team of Science Babes report that Huntsville Alabama is home to the first F-1 test and quals since 1969 and the first F-1 ever since 1973!
Wait....
"Science Babes Moonlighting as Race Queens" is not the actual title of this piece by Tan-Tan.
If Formula One hasn't existed since 1973 what's this guy going on about?
"What?..."
"Oh!..."
The Science Babes are at their other job in Les Mans, which caused my confusion as they're actually talking about...
The huge engines that powered the first stage of the Saturn 5 rocket which put 12 men on the moon and Skylab into orbit hasn't been built in 44 years. Contrary to popular belief the plans for these beast DO still exist, but they are in obsolete computer formats and of limited use.
You see, the Apollo program was so rushed that a lot of the little 'tweaks' that were found necessary to keep the rocket from failing. This was not fully appreciated until the '80s when NASA and USAF engineers noted that there were holes drilled and pieces added to some of the F-1s in museums...holes and fiddly bits that weren't on the plans. The engines were exploding during tests and the production crew did some trial and error modifications until the "splodies" stopped. Additional tweaks were added at the plant to facilitate production, so the F-1 plans are actually plans for an inefficient kerosene/LOX bomb.
Well, engineers in Huntsville have taken apart and are restoring some of these engines, which were discovered to be in remarkably good shape. This time making a note of Every.Single.Part. And. Hole. The plan is to do a computer model of the engine that is accurate, but they need to ensure that they are building it from a working engine...so.....
That's just a test of the engines gas generator from last year...
This project is the brainchild of Marshall Spaceflight center engineers who felt that they ought to DO something with the dozen or so F-1s lying around the research center. They've been calling in other rocketry companies to observe and consult. In addition they've been bringing in the few surviving Apollo engineers to work on this interesting side project...which has resulted in a tentative design and proposal for the F-1B
This is not as silly as it sounds. One of the things about the F-1 that was discovered back in the 60's was that, due to its very conservative design it was actually pretty re-useable and it was felt it could be made completely so with a few tweaks. F-1s were considered for several early space shuttle designs propelling reusable flyback boosters.
The mighty F-1 may yet again spew pillars of fire for the chariots of explorers.
1
One of the best scenes in Stratos 4 was when they did a full-power full duration test of the engine from the Stratos, mounted on a test stand, with a huge crowd watching.
2
Of course letting Aerojet to develop AJ-500 would be much too efficient and market oriented, and do nothing to make something to do for the Marshall Center in service of the government unnecessary launcher, which only exists because it's mandated by U.S. Senate.
Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at Tue Feb 25 11:10:31 2014 (RqRa5)
3
Keeping ones design staff occupied with actually designing and reverse engineering things is pretty important. Refurbishing engines that were laying about and tweaking them seems to be a decent idea....especially since they are bringing in private contractors to observe and learn. The rocketdyne poatents have probably expired by now so this could serve to provide the industry with a "public domain" heavy lift engine. I'm not convinced such a big rocket is needed, but some people like Zubrin are convinced it is a necessity for a manned Mars program. I'd rather not have them re-invent the wheel.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Tue Feb 25 13:22:01 2014 (DnAJl)
4
Zubrin has already re-calculated Mars Direct with FH. Note that super-heavy rockets are in fact necessary for crazy programs like Elon Musk's Mars colonization. Unfortunately, SLS does absolutely nothing for that. It's 100 times too expensive than required.
I'm all for keeping engineers current, especially since people at Marshall haven't done anything flying in decades -- enough for a generational turnover to wipe any expertise. Even Mike Griffin admitted that Ares I was basically a rocket with training wheels for them before designing Ares V (now SLS). The problem, however, is how all they build in the end is useless. If we just fire all of them and keep a skeletal staff just to steward the irreplaceable infrastructure such as test stands, the loss of expertise and capability is going to be minimal, as far as America is concerned. But the people bumped off government payroll might just find a productive employment however. Even being a WalMart greeter is more productive than designing SLS (in this case its boosters).
I relish in the thought that Marshall could kick ATK in the gonads if they ever make this F-1B work, but if it were possible to end the whole boondoggle, I would.
Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at Tue Feb 25 13:51:52 2014 (RqRa5)
Well, As Excuses Go
This probably should win some sort of award.
We've heard about the terrible smog problem in many Chinese cities and many of us assumed that it was a combination ofthe sheer scale of China's industrialization, perverse incentives, and corruption hindering enforcement of existing laws.
A Four Ring Circus of WIN Log Horizon has been discussed here before.
Since then it has continued to surpass expectations despite its unspectacular animation and dubious concept. The show has all the tropes one would expect from a fantasy adventure series, plus a great many in-jokes and references to online RPGs, however it uses them in very clever ways and is surprisingly intelligent.
21 episides in they still have 5 episodes to wreck it, but I'm going out on a limb recomending this one strongly. I started to do a regular review but this is a show spoilers will completely spoil, so here is a deliberately vague overview of what sorts of characters are involved in the three to four distinct but interlocking plots that stem from a mishap with a Massively Muliplayer Online Virtual Reality Role Playing Game that traps thousands of players in the game with no way to log out.
In Ring One:
We have our designated hero. He's overall a decent guy and goes to great lengths to do the right thing. He's not a frontline action hero however, and he tends to gets by on smarts, using game theory as well as working feverishly to develop political/interpersonal skills he'd never really had to (nor wanted to) pursue until just recently.
His lack of patience for such things causes him to resort to downright Machiavellian, even totalitarian methods to achieve his fairly noble ends....methods which seem to be coming back to haunt him.
We have a thoroughly conventional would-be love interest/side-kick. Well, not quite: She's so utterly smitten and so thoroughly into the "serving her noble master" roleplay that she's a little creepy and stalky. However she's really good at her job (which involves kicking ass, and cutting throats). She's also quite smart and her perceptiveness and different perspective on things is actually crucial to everyone's survival.
Also: It's always nice to find a DFC' in anime who is non-neurotic, utterly awesome and at ease with themselves.
There is one annoying, token lunkhead: He may have Tourettes as he frequently makes sexist comments despite the fact that they immediately result in great pain and temporary physical disability (see above).
We have an older gentleman who is intellectually curious enough to, on a lark, try something completely new (and apparently pointless) just to see what will happen. In the process, he changes the world.
In a complete break with convention, the old guy is not a perv and in fact prides himself in being a gentleman...in the very best sense of the word. He's an all round cool cat, whose urbane, almost aristocratic mannerisms belie an exemplary ethical compass plus great moral and physical courage.
In Ring Two:
We've got five teenagers who find a mixture of idealism, inexperience and bravado has subsequently landed them in a dire situation, far from help with the fate of thousands on their shoulders. Remarkably, all four young adults are striving to actually be adults...how's that for novel? Of course, as they're young, they're learning and everything they punch at is well above their weight. This is an action flick so everything can punch back....hard
The group includes a crackerjack young lady who, due to her levelheadedness and self discipline becomes their leader via acclaim. She's learning as she goes about the ins and outs of command and leadership, and doing everything she can to improve herself so that she can better keep her outmatched little party alive.
Her brother is a good man and physically brave, but, he's terribly inexperienced and it often seems that he has more balls than sense. He is however, indomitable in his determination and can think on his feet.
There is also a girl who has been through a special hell recently and is still somewhat traumatized from the experience. She's striving to confront her demons, improve herself and save her friends...all the while coming to terms with the sheer gravity of what she's lost.
An idealistic but grounded young woman who has sufficient grasp of her own limitations that she can use her limited talents to surprising effect. Her modesty belies her remarkable effectiveness in combat which acts as a nice foil to her polar opposite in the group...
...A dapper young man of 19 years who seems to be trying to somehow weaponize the Dunning-Kruger Effect. His boastfulness seems to be in direct proportion to his failings, of which there are many...physical courage, it should be noted, is not amongst them.
In Ring Three:
"Flyover Country" is actually much more important to the well being of us all than many who live in certain hip cities want to acknowledge.
I swear this is on topic.
The greatest test of ones character is when one finds that doing what is right requires one to make a sacrifice or take a great risk while simply walking away carries no negative judgement or cost.
Also in this ring: You magnificent bastard! You found a keeper!
In Ring Four:
There are also bout 20 different quirky supporting characters involved in a slice of life show about small businesses and local politics...oh and steam engineering and a war. Most of them are interesting enough and sufficiently fleshed out that the fanfic practically writes itself*.
**************************
Log Horizon has been very entertaining so far and frankly if I had kids this is the sort of show I'd be wanting them to watch. It's a show about courage, ethics, hope and even civics, where intelligence and thinking things through is important, experience matters because life lessons are hard earned and most of the protagonists are pretty decent people. It's also a surprisingly lacking in the gratuitous fan service department..one epic miniskirt notwithstanding.
Be advised though that the OP is an obnoxious, weaponized earworm.
Those who've been watching it, have at it in the comments. I'm curious what other people think.
Update: A few theories on what is actually going on
It's possible that the 'Adventurers' are not actually the players, but copies of players minds that were made when the update went live. The players may may actually be dead due to having their brains fried in the process. I base this on the fact that no-one has keeled over dead yet from their IRL selves starving. Of course we don't know WHAT is going on in the real world, and the few flashbacks to their gaming setups don't show any VR headsets or really any kit that would look out of place today, so it may be that the actual mechanics of the mishap are never going to be a plot point.
Akatzuki's changing her Avatar does beg the obvious question...how many of these comely wenchess are actually creepy old dudes? 80% or more? My money's on Henrietta being one.
The implications of the contract with Rudy are deeply problematic.
Spoiler tags here are as follows: [-S-P-O-I-L-E-R-] [/S-P-O-I-L-E-R-]
...but lower case and without any of the dashes
* As opposed to that other show where Tite Kubo got bogged down writing his own fanfic.
I kinda like the theory where some of the People of the Land are possessing the gamers' original bodies. Or the Knights and PotL with high classes. Or wizards. Or gods. Or goblins. Goblins and demihumans would be messy but cool.
Of course, now that we have an idea where the Knights went, this isn't quite as viable a theory.
I suppose that we could go with the adventurers' original bodies becoming golems, and sort of going about their business without much thought. (Cue satirical indictment of routine modern life.)
I also like the idea that this really is a matter of high-tech magic (or magic-like tech, or divine magic), and that the magic just got powerful enough to actually transport people's minds and spirits, and maybe their bodies too. In that case, I expect that the adventurers' original bodies are stockpiled somewhere, being magically sustained.
Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at Wed Feb 26 14:41:40 2014 (nh8FR)
2
Umm..Wait...
We KNOW were the Knights went? What episode was that in?
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Wed Feb 26 20:41:55 2014 (DnAJl)
3
"People who read spoilers about the manga know what's up with the Knights".
-j
Posted by: J Greely at Thu Feb 27 01:45:04 2014 (+cEg2)
It was a throwaway line in the most recent episode, unless I'm dreaming. Of course, I was watching pretty early in the morning on Saturday, so it's possible that I was! (Also, it's possible that their info was wrong.)
Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at Fri Feb 28 14:29:29 2014 (nh8FR)
3
I'm only surprised someone didn't draw back a bloody stump from that stunt. My cats would be spinning balls of claws if that happened to them.
Posted by: Mitch H. at Thu Feb 20 10:52:23 2014 (jwKxK)
4
I have heard for many years a possibly apocryphal story that the video
source of the .gif is usually cut short of the point that the experiment
became a study of human blood in freefall.
In any event, Jerry Pournelle relates this anecdote....
And prior to (the) Mercury (program) we hadn't any real experience at all. We flew transport planes in parabolic courses that might give as much as 30 seconds of almost-zero-g, and that was
all we knew. I will not soon forget some of our early low-g experiments.
Some genius wanted to know how a cat oriented: visual cues, or a
gravity sensor? The obvious way to find out was to take a cat up in an
airplane, fly the plane in a parabolic orbit, and observe the cat during
the short period of zero-g.
It made sense. Maybe. It didn't make enough that anyone would
authorize a large airplane for the experiment, so a camera was mounted
in a small fighter (perhaps a T-bird; I forget), and the cat was carried
along in the pilot's lap. A movie was made of the whole run.
The film, I fear, doesn't tell us how a cat orients. It shows the
pilot frantically trying to tear the cat off his arm, and the cat just
as violently resisting. Eventually the cat was broken free and let go in
mid-air, where it seemed magically (teleportation? or not really zero
gravity in the plane? no one knows) to move, rapidly, straight back to
the pilot, claws outstretched. This time there was no tearing it loose
at all. The only thing I learned from the film is that cats (or this one
anyway) don't like zero gravity, and think human beings are the obvious
point of stability to cling to...
From A STEP FARTHER OUT by Jerry Pournelle, 1979
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Thu Feb 20 19:55:48 2014 (DnAJl)
5
This gif is from later, we know because of the women. The earlier experiment were men-only.
6
Oh yes. Dr. Pournelle's example took place in a fighter as well. The point was that NASA conducted at least two experiments that seem to imply that taking cats into space is contra-indicated.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Fri Feb 21 02:56:23 2014 (DnAJl)
7
By contrast, dogs don't seem to have much of a problem.
While finding that, I spotted another amusing/horrifying "do a barrel roll" video (I'd seen this one before; skip to about 1:50.)
Posted by: RickC at Fri Feb 21 14:27:12 2014 (ECH2/)
8
The cats in this video didn't seem to do do badly. There's even a few seconds of pigeons flying.
Posted by: RickC at Fri Feb 21 14:35:38 2014 (ECH2/)
1
Damn, and I didn't know about it either. It's awesome that they made it though.
And reading the extra stuff, I noticed a few things. Silly things like Enutrof (Ruel's race) is "Fortune" spelled backwards, likewise, Nox is a "Xelor", which is especially appropriate considering his plan.
Posted by: Mauser at Wed Feb 19 04:06:49 2014 (TJ7ih)
Happy Presidents Day
In compliance with FCC requirements that a certain percentage of our content be educational, we feel we should point to this...
...and take time to educate our readers about the fact that the United States played no part in Gallipoli or the Battle of Verdun, both of which took place before the US declared war in 1917.
That Sinking Feeling
...Honorious must have felt as he pondered ruefully upon the wisdom of rounding out his army's order of battle with Visigoths....that he was in considerable debt to.
The United States has become so dependent on Chinese imports, however,
that the F.D.A. may not be able to do much about the Chinese refusal.
The crucial ingredients for nearly all antibiotics, steroids and many
other lifesaving drugs are now made exclusively in China.
Now That Singles Awareness Day Has Passed
..it is probably a good time to remind people of the importance of stoicism...and failing that, knowing when to shut up.
When asked by a reporter how he felt about the recent record snowfall in Tokyo, this fellow seems to have given an answer so sappy that it broke the very soul of the young lady on his arm. To add to the couples mutual mortification the interview quickly went viral and....well...
Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at Mon Feb 17 10:02:25 2014 (RqRa5)
6
Aside from the pictures, I find the expressed jealosy and hatred remarkable. MSM keeps telling us that Japanese gave up, do not want, etc. Well... Maybe they gave up, but perhaps just because they're too busy/lazy, and not because manga and games make a full substitute.
Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at Mon Feb 17 10:04:58 2014 (RqRa5)
7
Yeah, now that you mention it, the venom directed at this guy is a bit hard to fathom. I'm not sure if it's a cultural thing because his statement came off as boastful, (and therefore gauche) or it's just bitter jealousy.
I thought it was kind of a funny/cute story and felt for both of them, but you're right, the hateorade is indeed flowing.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Mon Feb 17 21:06:19 2014 (DnAJl)
Director Carl Rinch gives the classic tale of Bushido a supernatural twist. The film boasts an all star cast of Japanese A-listers including Hiroyuki Sanada, Ko Shibasaki, Tadanobu Asano, Min Tanaka and Jin Akashini. They are joined by Keneau Reeves portraying a magical honkey who teaches our heroes an important lesson in respect and tolerance.
Despite that...last bit, this is not a bad film. It is rather strange though.
A brief narration gives a decent overview of the political situation in 18th century Japan and the fact that this film is based on a historical event...shortly before introducing the audience to some really impressive supernatural weirdness. This is a Japan where the Tengu and other Yokai are real and can be quite dangerous. Thanks in part to the supernatural element, Reeves's character is not entirely egregious and his incongruous presence actually serves to establish the decency of the Lord Asano character ( Min Tanaka). In spite of a somewhat dubious romantic subplot between him and Ko Shibasaki, Reeves is, at best a deutoragonist and, in fact Hirouki Sanada as Oishi emerges in his historical role as the lead. This is actually a fairly straightforward retelling of the story....Well....aside from a much grander scale, the occasional supernatural horror, and Pirates of the Caribbean homages. This is all done with an astonishing amount of what appears to be...sincerity.
47 Ronin is a pretty odd film, but if one HAD to somehow work Keneau Reeves into this story, this is about as respectful to the source material as one could hope for. If one wanted to remake this film without the supernatural elements...well, there's no point in that because Hiroshi Inegaki nailed it in 1962. As it is, this is a pretty good popcorn flick that, surprisingly, does not cop out on the point of the story. It's even clever at times with a few moments of 'fridge brilliance'
In a flashback at the beginning of the film Reeve's character (as a child) escaped from a group of Tengu who had raised him (he was abandoned in the forest due to his being of mixed race) At one point he confesses this to Oishi...stating that he left because while the group that raised were always kind to him, they had a nihilistic philosophy and considered human life only a path to suffering and death..a path they aim to end. A bit later , when Reeves is functioning as the heroes expert on things supernatural. we encounter the monstrous & secretive tribe of Yokai who raised him...They're supernatural ....Buddhist monks...The implication seems to be that Reeve's character had simply missed an important point regards the 4 noble truths.
*************
Given that, aside from the aforementioned group, the Tengu and their human associates as seen are pretty dangerous and malevolent, there is a perfectly rational reason why Oishi does not initially trust Reeves character. This sets in motion the tragedy of the first part of the film, which transpires because Oishi initially does not heed Reeves warning.
I admit I went into this with low expectations, but, while no great work of art, it is a surprisingly solid film.
1
And since, in the 18th and 19th century, long-beaked tengu were strongly associated with big-nosed American and European guys as well as with teaching swordsmanship and other skills and knowledge....
Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at Sat Feb 15 18:38:45 2014 (cvXSV)
Posted by: Mauser at Thu Feb 13 04:35:19 2014 (TJ7ih)
2
"I hold with those who favor fire.
But if it had to perish twice,
I think I know enough of hate
To say that for destruction ice
Is also great
And would suffice. "
Posted by: Doug O at Thu Feb 13 11:11:08 2014 (aSh73)
3
He was only asking "What do you want?".
Of course, some favors come at too high a price.
Posted by: topmaker at Thu Feb 13 18:46:48 2014 (2yZsg)
4
"Bugs, Mr Rico! Zillions of 'em! I'm a-burnin' them down."
"Hughes, take a close look at those Bugs. Any of them fighting back? Aren't they all workers?"
"Uh... hey! How'd you know?"
Posted by: Wonderduck at Thu Feb 13 20:23:32 2014 (dc/G/)
5
Greatest TV monster creation ever. Makes no sense, mind you, but still...
I will grant you that the groundhog does seem to be screaming "Buuuuuuuggggsss".
If they do remake that movie, I hope someone actually reads the book.
Posted by: topmaker at Fri Feb 14 13:05:34 2014 (2yZsg)
Obviously do what your doctor says first, but those whey protein things that weightlifters eat to help them recover from tearing up their muscles on purpose in exercise? They really did help me recover faster from breaking my arm, and I was a sedentary middle-aged lady with extreme laziness about doing physical therapy. I ate a lot of whole eggs, too. Protein and viteys do help. I bet you get to eat a lot of bananas and electrolytes too.
Ankle injuries are always awkward, because you end up either having to put weight on them, or doing a lot of hopping and/or crutching. On the bright side, you can read a lot of blogs by people who run or jog, and beat up their feet like this all the time by choice. You can get some good tips that way, or learn from horrible examples.
Seriously, it's scary to get injured like this, but you have the tools to understand what's going on and to help yourself recover. Also, you have a good excuse to sit on your butt in the warm and watch anime! It's not all bad!
Posted by: suburbanbanshee at Fri Feb 7 21:51:23 2014 (cvXSV)
2
Work hard. As unpleasant as it is, physical therapy is only as effective as you make it. Some of what they had me do was painful, and some was boring, but I put everything I had into it, and I'm glad I did.
After I fell off a loading dock back in '92, turning the ligaments and
cartilage in my right ankle into what the doctor termed "confetti!" with
a cheerful tone in his voice, I was on crutches for six months, and a
cane for another eight. I did not put enough effort into my therapy as I
should have.
As a result, while it did heal after a fashion, my ankle doesn't like
much in the way of uncommon stresses. For a while, I could sprain it
just by sneezing (or at least it felt that way). Now, some 20+ years
later, the internals of my ankle are a solid mass of scar tissue. It
still functions like an ankle, just... reluctantly and with more than a
bit of pain.
There is a grand total of fsck-all medical science can do about it.
So do your rehab, and buy lots of bags of frozen peas.
Posted by: Wonderduck at Sat Feb 8 04:30:59 2014 (mOdOJ)
4
There is a happy medium. You want to work hard on your physical therapy, but you also don't want to push yourself so hard that you hurt yourself again.
In my defense of my questionable sanity... while I was somewhat lazy about a few elements of my official physical therapy, I actually pushed myself a fair amount in small cheaty ways at work, or when performing other activities, because that's the kind of idiot I am. They had me come in a couple-three times a week to the therapy place, also, so I was actually putting in a good workout pretty often. If they had only had me coming in once a week or less, my laziness on certain exercises would probably have had bad consequences. (And I probably would have made myself do more official therapy, because the inabilities would have been worse and hence more annoying.) Also, I'm just naturally flexible in ways which are not normally useful (or even noticeable to me), but which made therapy work faster for me than for some.
Still, it's better to do what the therapist tells you, rather than rely on cheaty stuff in the background or your body sliding you out of trouble. Especially since ankles are a lot more trouble than arms. Doing all the exercises in their proper amounts helps keeps your muscles and joints balanced out as you go along, and thus helps prevent bad stuff happening.
But yeah, make sure you eat good, because you need fuel, protein, and vitamins and minerals to heal. Talk to your doctor about it, and he'll probably have plenty to say.
And it'll be spring and summer before you know it, and you'll be feeling much better by then.
Posted by: suburbanbanshee at Sun Feb 9 10:20:49 2014 (cvXSV)
5
Well, If the defect isn't fixed in 6 weeks I'll need surgery eventually. Eventually means this year because of the moonless unlit road that represents how much I know what my health insurance will be after the first of the year, so If the therapy does not fix the problem, I'm looking at six weeks out of work and possibly school this spring/summer.
My motivation is rather high.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Sun Feb 9 21:15:36 2014 (DnAJl)
My other piece of advice: Sometimes you get to a point where you're not hurting yet, but you feel like crud for no particular reason. And then you realize that actually your bones and muscles are aching, and that pretty soon it will get worse.
This is the time to make sure you don't forget to take your pain pills.
Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at Tue Feb 11 14:34:48 2014 (nh8FR)
Thinking Small With Regard to Surface ships
CDR Phillip Pournelle has an interesting guest post over at Galrhan's place in which he discusses the potential that small combatants have to augment the USN's force structure. He specifically references the Coast Guard's new Sentinel Class patrol boats.
I’ll add here another comparison: For the cost of one Littoral Combat
ship with two helicopters we could deploy 14 Sentinel class patrol craft
with increased firepower within the displacement capabilities of the
hull design.
The Sentinel's are fine vessels, with great seakeeping for their size and enough range to cross the Pacific (via Hawaii). They are actually a Dutch design purchased because of its very good performance in several Navies & Coast Guards. However, it's unclear what increased firepower can realistically be added to the Sentinel design. Remember, it's not just displacement that is important, space is a big factor in guided
missile systems and in the sensors, fire control and C4i systems needed to make any armament useful.
Still, being conservative, lets assume that any up-gunning consisted of replacing the Bushmaster Cannon with the 'bolt on' SEA RAM missile system (which has its own fire control on the mount) and squeezing in two Penguin antiship missiles between the cutters copious ventilators. I choose these two systems because they are both designed to have low impact and be mounted on austere or even civilian vessels, both are in US service and they are fairly cheap. The LCS has 21 point defense anti-air missiles (RAM) and no antiship missiles except for some antitank missiles that have a shorter range than the ships single Bofors gun. Bu contrast the postulated 14 Coast guard cutters, for the same price would have have 154 of the same type of point defense missiles and 28 over the horizon ship killing missiles. That's 133 more SAMs and 28 more SSMs and they'd be (at least) 14 times as hard to sink (perhaps harder, as the Coast Guard cutters are made of steel as opposed to aluminum).
All this really tells us is that comparing anything against the Navy's littoral combat ship is setting the bar rather low.
However 14 vessels would take at least 14 hits to put out of action and so might deny any enemy unfettered use of an area of water longer. Also 14 hulls can be in 14 places at once, which can be important in peace as well as war. Showing the flag, for instance, requires the flag actually be present.
On the debit side, while it's true that 14 cutters could cover a similar
area to the LCS's helicopters, they'd be somewhat less flexible and, of
course they'd not have anything like the huge cargo bay. It might be
advisable to apply the concept to a somewhat larger, but still austere
vessel. The Italian Commandante class Corvettes, are austere offshore patrol vessels that come in at 58 million (US) apiece which compares favorably to the Sentinel's 47 million dollar price tag.
The closeness in price between a 400 ton and a 1500 ton vessel may cause some alarm, but it is a good reminder that steel, as opposed to a weapon system or sensor array, is cheap. A bigger hull costs only a little more.
The Coast Guard needed a vessel that could go really close inshore, have a crew of under 30, have a low enough freeboard to pull people out of the water from the main deck, sip fuel, be based at existing small boat stations and have a draft of less than 10 feet. As such the 400 ton cutters are good fit for their needs...the operating costs are much lower (fuel, crew ect) are far smaller than the larger ship....(acquisition costs are only part of a budget).
However, 1100 more tons of steel buys a lot better seakeepng, a helicopter and vastly more internal space with all the associated advantages... at the cost of some increased operating costs due to a much larger crew and greater fuel consumption. 12 can be bought for the cost of a single 700 million LCS, though how much 12 would cost to run in comparison to an LCS is unclear though the LCS is notoriously expensive in fuel and repair costs. 12 of these ships bring 12 helicopters to the table as opposed to the LCS's 2 and the Comandante class has a hard point for 4 or 8 antiship missiles. There is also a provision in the design for a slightly stretched version with 8VLS cells and 32 ESSM missiles...
...but at that point you're getting into a AAA fire control systems, with the attendant risk of escalating prices to the point of missing the raison' detre' of the exercise.
Still, if the cost could be kept to the point that 6-10 could be bought and operated for the cost of an LCS then this vessel could be a vast quantitative and qualitative improvement over LCS.
Additionally, we've mentioned before that the French have a very interesting smaller (800 ton) vessel with similar features, but no costs were available.
Such vessels are no replacement for the big Destroyers, with their sensors and ability to shoot down aircraft missiles and satellites as well as strike targets a thousand miles away, but they could be an interesting force multiplier for a reasonable price. This is going to become a very important consideration in the coming years. when our older hulls start wearing out...just as the depth of our financial crisis becomes fully felt
This Bodes Ill
Snowmelt from the Sierra Nevada mountans is where the water in southern California, Nevada and to an extent, Arizona comes from.
This is what snowfall in the Sierra Nevada looked like on January 18 of 2013, which was actually a very bad drought year.
This is what it looked like on the same date this year..
There is more here (via)
Forget the agricultural debacle for a moment...water for the cities is going to be a first order calamity. It's already pretty bad.
1
Glad you're back in the swing of things! (Or in the case of this illo, the metal....) Also glad you've gotten to catch up with Log Horizon, judging by the comment you left over at my place.
So are they going to make you do exercises with those freaky rubber things that you tie to doorknobs? Or do they do different therapies with feet?
Posted by: suburbanbanshee at Thu Feb 6 07:15:24 2014 (cvXSV)
The Gregorian calender does not have any predictive qualities beyond such matters as when a leap day will be inserted. The parallels between today and 1914 while real, are far from exact and have been developing for years.They do not gain special effectiveness by this grim centennial.
…it’s not comforting to ponder that Chinese who believe in traditional
five elements fortunetelling are of the opinion that Yang years of the
Wood Horse are associated with war — and "fast victories.†It is a year
to stick to one’s principles — which in this version means not
negotiating and running over other people.
Hobby Space News of the commercial space industry A Babe In The Universe Rather Eclectic Cosmology Encyclopedia Astronautica Superb spacecraft resource The Unwanted Blog Scott Lowther blogs about forgotten aerospace projects and sells amazingly informative articles on the same. Also, there are cats. Transterrestrial Musings Commentary on Infinity...and beyond! Colony WorldsSpace colonization news! The Alternate Energy Blog It's a blog about alternate energy (DUH!) Next Big Future Brian Wang: Tracking our progress to the FUTURE. Nuclear Green Charles Barton, who seems to be either a cool curmudgeon, or a rational hippy, talks about energy policy and the terrible environmental consequences of not going nuclear Energy From Thorium Focuses on the merits of thorium cycle nuclear reactors WizBang Current events commentary...with a wiz and a bang The Gates of Vienna Tenaciously studying a very old war The Anchoress insightful blogging, presumably from the catacombs Murdoc Online"Howling Mad Murdoc" has a millblog...golly! EaglespeakMaritime security matters Commander Salamander Fullbore blackshoe blogging! Belmont Club Richard Fernandez blogs on current events BaldilocksUnderstated and interesting blog on current events The Dissident Frogman French bi-lingual current events blog The "Moderate" VoiceI don't think that word means what they think it does....but this lefty blog is a worthy read nonetheless. Meryl Yourish News, Jews and Meryls' Views Classical Values Eric Scheie blogs about the culture war and its incompatibility with our republic. Jerry Pournell: Chaos ManorOne of Science fictions greats blogs on futurism, current events, technology and wisdom A Distant Soil The website of Colleen Dorans' superb fantasy comic, includes a blog focused on the comic industry, creator issues and human rights. John C. Wright The Sci-Fi/ Fantasy writer muses on a wide range of topics. Now Read This! The founder of the UK Comics Creators Guild blogs on comics past and present. The Rambling Rebuilder Charity, relief work, roleplaying games Rats NestThe Art and rantings of Vince Riley Gorilla Daze Allan Harvey, UK based cartoonist and comics historian has a comicophillic blog! Pulpjunkie Tim Driscoll reviews old movies, silents and talkies, classics and clunkers. Suburban Banshee Just like a suburban Leprechaun....but taller, more dangerous and a certified genius. Satharn's Musings Through TimeThe Crazy Catlady of The Barony of Tir Ysgithr アニ・ノート(Ani-Nouto) Thoughtful, curmudgeonly, otakuism that pulls no punches and suffers no fools. Chizumatic Stephen Den Beste analyzes anime...with a microscope, a slide rule and a tricorder. Wonderduck Anime, Formula One Racing, Sad Girls in Snow...Duck Triumphalism Beta Waffle What will likely be the most thoroughly tested waffle evah! Zoopraxiscope Too In this thrilling sequel to Zoopraxiscope, Don, Middle American Man of Mystery, keeps tabs on anime, orchids, and absurdities. Mahou Meido MeganekkoUbu blogs on Anime, computer games and other non-vital interests Twentysided More geekery than you can shake a stick at Shoplifting in the Marketplace of Ideas Sounds like Plaigarism...but isn't Ambient IronyAll Meenuvians Praise the lathe of the maker! Hail Pixy!!