February 23, 2014

A Four Ring Circus of WIN

Log Horizon has been discussed here before.
Since then it has continued to surpass expectations despite its unspectacular animation and dubious concept. The show has all the tropes one would expect from a fantasy adventure series, plus a great many in-jokes and references to online RPGs, however it uses them in very clever ways and is surprisingly intelligent.

21 episides in they still have 5 episodes to wreck it, but I'm going out on a limb recomending this one strongly. I started to do a regular review but this is a show spoilers will completely spoil, so here is a deliberately vague overview of  what sorts of characters are involved in the three to four distinct but interlocking plots that stem from a mishap with a Massively Muliplayer Online Virtual Reality Role Playing Game that traps thousands of players in the game with no way to log out.

In Ring One:

We have our designated hero. He's overall a decent guy and goes to great lengths to do the right thing. He's not a frontline action hero however, and he tends to gets by on smarts, using game theory as well as working feverishly to develop political/interpersonal skills he'd never really had to (nor wanted to) pursue until just recently.

We have a thoroughly conventional would-be love interest/side-kick. Well, not quite: She's so utterly smitten and so thoroughly into the "serving her noble master" roleplay that she's a little creepy and stalky. However she's really good at her job (which involves kicking ass, and cutting throats). She's also quite smart and her perceptiveness and different perspective on things is actually crucial to everyone's survival.
Also: It's always nice to find a DFC' in anime who is non-neurotic, utterly awesome and at ease with themselves.

There is one annoying, token lunkhead: He may have Tourettes as he frequently makes sexist comments despite the fact that they immediately result in great pain and temporary physical disability (see above).

We have an older gentleman who is intellectually curious enough to, on a lark, try something completely new (and apparently pointless) just to see what will happen. In the process, he changes the world.
In a complete break with convention, the old guy is not a perv and in fact prides himself in being a gentleman...in the very best sense of the word. He's an all round cool cat, whose urbane, almost aristocratic mannerisms belie an exemplary ethical  compass plus great moral and physical courage.

In Ring Two:

We've got five teenagers who find a mixture of idealism, inexperience  and bravado has subsequently landed them in a dire situation, far from help with the fate of thousands on their shoulders.  Remarkably, all four young adults are striving to actually be adults...how's that for novel? Of course, as they're young, they're learning and everything they punch at is well above their weight. This is an action flick so everything can punch back....hard

The group includes a crackerjack young lady who, due to her levelheadedness and self discipline becomes their leader via acclaim.  She's learning as she goes about the ins and outs of command and leadership, and doing everything she can to improve herself so that she can better keep her outmatched little party alive.

Her brother is a good man and physically brave, but, he's terribly inexperienced and it often seems that he has more balls than sense. He is however, indomitable in his determination and can think on his feet.

  There is also a girl who has been through a special hell recently and is still somewhat traumatized from the experience. She's striving to confront her demons, improve herself and save her friends...all the while coming to terms with the sheer gravity of what she's lost.

An idealistic but grounded young woman who has sufficient grasp of her own limitations that she can use her limited talents to surprising effect. Her modesty belies her remarkable effectiveness in combat which acts as a nice foil to her polar opposite in the group...

...A dapper young man of 19 years who seems to be trying to somehow weaponize the Dunning-Kruger Effect. His boastfulness seems to be in direct proportion to his failings, of which there are many...physical courage, it should be noted, is not amongst them.

In Ring Three:

The greatest test of ones character is when one finds that doing what is right requires one to make a sacrifice or take a great risk while simply walking away carries no negative judgement or cost.

Also in this ring: You magnificent bastard! You found a keeper!

In Ring Four:

There are also bout 20 different quirky supporting characters involved in a slice of life show about small businesses and local politics...oh and steam engineering and a war. Most of them are interesting enough and sufficiently fleshed out that the fanfic practically writes itself*.

  Log Horizon has been very entertaining so far and frankly if I had kids this is the sort of show I'd be wanting them to watch. It's a show about courage, ethics, hope and even civics, where intelligence and thinking things through is important, experience matters because life lessons are hard earned and most of the protagonists are pretty decent people.  It's also a surprisingly lacking in the gratuitous fan service department..one epic miniskirt notwithstanding.

Be advised though that the OP is an obnoxious, weaponized earworm.

 Those who've been watching it, have at it in the comments. I'm curious what other people think.

A few theories on what is actually going on

Spoiler tags here are as follows:
[-S-P-O-I-L-E-R-] [/S-P-O-I-L-E-R-]   
...but lower case and without any of the dashes

* As opposed to that other show where Tite Kubo got bogged down writing his own fanfic.

Posted by: The Brickmuppet at 05:22 PM | Comments (5) | Add Comment
Post contains 249 words, total size 9 kb.


Of course, now that we have an idea where the Knights went, this isn't quite as viable a theory.

I suppose that we could go with the adventurers' original bodies becoming golems, and sort of going about their business without much thought. (Cue satirical indictment of routine modern life.)

I also like the idea that this really is a matter of high-tech magic (or magic-like tech, or divine magic), and that the magic just got powerful enough to actually transport people's minds and spirits, and maybe their bodies too. In that case, I expect that the adventurers' original bodies are stockpiled somewhere, being magically sustained.

Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at Wed Feb 26 14:41:40 2014 (nh8FR)

2 Umm..Wait...

Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Wed Feb 26 20:41:55 2014 (DnAJl)

3 "People who read spoilers about the manga know what's up with the Knights".


Posted by: J Greely at Thu Feb 27 01:45:04 2014 (+cEg2)


It was a throwaway line in the most recent episode, unless I'm dreaming. Of course, I was watching pretty early in the morning on Saturday, so it's possible that I was! (Also, it's possible that their info was wrong.)

Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at Fri Feb 28 14:29:29 2014 (nh8FR)


Or I may have misinterpreted the line. It was in that section about what's going on in the other Japanese cities.

Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at Fri Feb 28 14:30:47 2014 (nh8FR)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
40kb generated in CPU 0.0968, elapsed 0.876 seconds.
69 queries taking 0.8645 seconds, 322 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.